Best Baby Crib Mattress

Best Baby Crib Mattress reviews

Brief: Best Baby Crib Mattresses

  1. Introduction:
    • Importance of a high-quality baby crib mattress for a newborn’s growth and development.
    • Selection can be challenging due to diverse options and individual needs.
  2. Top 5 Best Baby Crib Mattresses:
    1. Best Overall: Colgate Eco Classica III
    2. Best Organic: Naturepedic Organic Classic
    3. Best Two-Sided: Moonlight Little Star Organic Crib Mattress
    4. Best Innerspring: Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib
    5. Best Budget: Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress
  3. Features:
    • Crib mattresses differ in size, material, and structure compared to regular mattresses.
    • Ideal crib mattresses are made with memory foam, latex, or gel for comfort.
    • Considerations include crib size, type, and child’s age and weight.
  4. Buyer’s Guide:
    • Emphasizes the need for high-quality, durable mattresses.
    • Factors to consider: materials, firmness, safety, and comfort.
    • Importance of selecting the right mattress for a child’s early years.
  5. Conclusion:
    • Emphasizes the importance of selecting the right crib mattress.
    • Compares the process of choosing a college major, highlighting the need for careful consideration.
    • Recommends focusing on sleep safety certifications, materials, price, durability, firmness, and types of crib mattresses.

The best baby crib mattress can do a great deal to help a newborn get the rest they need to grow and develop healthily. But buying a good one is more complicated than you think, since there are several options to choose from, and each one is different.

There is no universal mattress because everyone has different needs and preferences. If you’re a first-time parent, you probably don’t know what those preferences are yet. As a result, picking a mattress can be sort of like picking a college major: you don’t know what you want until you see what’s out there.

It is similar to regular mattresses, but they are smaller to fit in a crib. The best crib mattresses are made with the best materials like memory foam, latex, and gel. All of these materials have their benefits and drawbacks. Some baby crib mattresses are made with multiple layers of foam for maximum comfort.

Top 5 Best Baby Crib Mattresses

Naturepedic Organic Classic Baby Crib Mattresses
Naturepedic Organic Classic Baby Crib Mattresses
  • Sizes: 27 1/4″ x 51 5/8″ x 6″
  • Construction Type: Innerspring
  • Materials: Cotton fabric + fill, PLA layer, Steel
  • Price: $$

You need to make sure that the crib mattress that you choose for your baby is of high quality and durability. If you are trying to find the best crib mattress for your baby, then you have come to the right place.

The crib’s size, the type of crib, and the child’s age and weight are all factors to consider when making a purchase, as the mattress may need to be replaced more than once.

This review concentrates on the top 5 baby crib mattresses and the various materials that crib mattresses are made.

Best Baby Crib Mattresses Reviews


Colgate Eco Classica Baby Crib Mattresses

Best Overall

The Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress offers a mattress made with an eco-friendly core that provides a firm feel for your infant and a softer feel for a toddler. So, if you’re looking for a dual-firmness crib mattress that is made naturally, then it is the one for you.

The waterproof outer layer is made of soft organic cotton that gives it durability and is also breathable and helps regulate the baby’s temperature. It’s also free of allergens, chemicals, and toxins.

The mattress is dual-sided and has two firmness levels, making it easy to transition babies from their crib to their toddler bed.

What We Like

  • It is made from 100% organic cotton and is made in the USA.
  • It is waterproof.
  • The mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified, so it’s safe and healthy for the baby to sleep on.

What We Don’t Like

  • It is more expensive than a regular crib mattress.


Naturepedic Organic Classic Baby Crib Mattresses

Best Organic Crib Mattress

Naturepedic’s Organic Crib Mattress has been on the market for over 20 years and has become a popular choice among consumers seeking a non-toxic mattress for their baby. The mattress is made from organic cotton and consists of two layers: a firm top layer and a more cushion bottom layer.

The combination of the two layers allows a baby to sleep on a firm surface that will support growing bones and a soft surface that will provide the baby with comfort. The mattress is free of any harmful chemicals such as polyurethane, latex, phthalates, flame retardants, or synthetic fragrances. It comes with a removable, machine-washable organic cotton cover.

For parents looking for a hypoallergenic crib mattress that will provide their little one with a restful night’s sleep, the Naturepedic organic crib mattress is a great choice.

What We Like

  • It has a waterproof, natural fabric cover.
  • It is both organic and all-natural — meaning the baby won’t be exposed to any harmful chemicals.
  • Likewise, it’s exceptionally lightweight and easy to transport and fit in any crib.

What We Don’t Like

  • The cotton may get dirty and eventually have to be thrown away, and the mattress might not fit in all cribs.
  • It is more expensive than a regular crib mattress.


Moonlight Little Star Organic Crib Mattress

Best Two-Sided Crib Mattress

Moonlight Little Star Organic Crib Mattress is both a firm and soft mattress, making it a versatile choice. It will provide proper support and comfort to infants while being gentle enough for toddlers. 

This mattress is built with dual-firmness. This allows it to be firm enough to support an infant properly but soft enough to relieve the pressure a toddler would put on it. The mattress is also very durable. It is made from plant-infused foam, firm, and stable on one side, and soft and pressure-relieving. 

The removable cover is stain-resistant and waterproof. It is machine washable, so it will be easy to keep.

The Moonlight Little Star Organic Crib Mattress is free of nasty chemicals and additives such as pesticides, phthalates, vinyl, lead, chlorine, and other toxic materials.

What We Like

  • The Moonlight Little Star Organic Crib Mattress is sold in a standard size that will fit into a crib.
  • The mattress comprises several layers, with a top layer made of an organic cotton cover.
  • The memory foam will provide the mattress with firm support.
  • It is waterproof, and this is a feature that is important for a mattress.
  • The mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified, so it’s safe and healthy for the baby to sleep on.

What We Don’t Like

  • Not completely organic.


Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress

Best Innerspring Mattresses

The Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress is the perfect mattress to make your nursery complete. Holding to Serta’s passion for quality, this mattress is constructed with non-toxic and fire retardant-free materials and will provide the perfect firmness for your baby or toddler. It will help them sleep soundly and wake up feeling refreshed.

Serta’s dual-side feature also allows you to reverse the mattress’s firmness to match your child’s age. Whether your child is a baby learning to sit up or your toddler just learning to walk, the 120 heavy-duty coils of the crib side will provide the support they need.

The Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress is the only crib mattress in the U.S.A. made without chemicals. It earned the prestigious GREENGUARD Gold certification – the highest environmental standard for indoor air quality.

The vinyl cover is water-resistant, so your baby can sleep on a clean surface throughout the night.

What We Like

  • The Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress contain no PBDE fire retardants, lead, formaldehyde, or other harmful chemicals, and it is made without ozone depletion.
  • It is waterproof.
  • It earned the prestigious GREENGUARD Gold certification.

What We Don’t Like

  • The mattress is thin, so it is prone to occasional indents.


Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress

Best Budget

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress is an excellent option if you are looking for a safe and affordable mattress for your children.

It is also straightforward to clean. The vinyl cover is water-resistant, so if a spill should occur, you can wipe it off immediately. 

It is made with a high-density thermo-bonded fiber core so that your child will have the support they need to feel comfortable and secure.

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress is a great choice for keeping babies and toddlers safe and comfortable. It is made from a hypoallergenic material free from flame retardants and latex, it is also free from lead and phthalates. 

It is designed to fit standard cribs, making it the right choice for parents who don’t want to buy a new crib but want to ensure their little one is safe and comfortable.

What We Like

  • It is lightweight.
  • Affordable.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • It earned the prestigious GREENGUARD Gold certification.

What We Don’t Like

  • It retains more heat than some other foam mattresses.

Buyer’s Guide

A crib mattress is one of the most important pieces of baby furniture you can buy. It will be your baby’s bed for the first few years of his life, so you want to be sure you choose the right one. There are several things to look for when shopping for one, including materials, firmness, safety, and comfort. To help you make an informed decision, we have put together this crib mattress buyer’s guide.

What to Look for In a Crib Mattress?

So you’re looking to buy a crib mattress. What do you need to consider? Since the mattress you buy for your baby will be taking the brunt of all those early naps and late-night feedings, it’s important to choose a high-quality product that will give your little one many years of comfortable support. But what factors should you consider? Here are the things you need to think about before picking out a crib mattress:

Sleep Safety Certifications

Sleep safety is a big deal because even though many parents would do anything to help their children sleep better, they don’t always know which products will be the safest. For instance, some parents may assume that the most expensive crib mattress is the best one, but that may not be true. A safe crib mattress is one that meets the latest safety standards.

As a result, many parents will turn to a crib mattress that has been certified by an organization such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). And while you may think that this is a good idea, it’s essential to know that the CPSC’s certification is voluntary. If a manufacturer chooses not to participate, its crib mattresses may still reach consumers.


When purchasing a crib mattress, remember that it will be the surface your child will sleep on for the first several years of his or her life, so it’s important to choose a mattress that is safe and comfortable.

So what is the difference between the materials found in a crib mattress? Mainly, it is the quality and durability of the materials. It is common sense that the crib mattress materials be of very high quality as they are in constant contact with the baby.

The baby’s mattress should be made from non-toxic material. The mattress should be breathable and be able to absorb sweat and urine. It should not be too firm or too soft. The materials used for crib mattresses are natural latex, organic cotton, innerspring, foam rubber, and memory foam.


Mattresses come in all shapes and sizes, and the price of a crib mattress is no exception. First, you need to decide what you’re looking for in a mattress. If you’re focused on quality, your budget will be higher. However, if you are concerned about cost, you can find comparable mattresses for less. Mattresses on the low end of the price range are often made with cheaper materials, however, they can still be comfortable and sturdy.


Durability is one of the most important factors to consider when you are buying a crib mattress. Not only do you want it to be safe, but you want it to last. Many factors affect the durability of a mattress, including the kind of foam used, the materials it’s made of, construction techniques, and the type of cover that it has. So, how can you determine if a mattress is durable?

The quality of the materials used, along with the brand’s reputation, will determine how long a crib mattress will last.

Crib mattresses are often made of soft rubber and filled with layers of foam. These mattresses are designed to last from six to twelve months. 

The crib mattress should be firm, and there should be no depression in the center. The edges should be smooth, and there should be no tears or holes. A crib mattress should also be waterproof and easy to clean. This is especially important if you have a baby who is still drinking from a bottle. The mattress should be able to be cleaned with soap and warm water.


When choosing a crib mattress, sleep firmness is a key factor to consider. How vital is firmness when choosing the crib mattress, though? Starters need to remember three different types of mattresses: innerspring, foam, and airbed.

A good crib mattress will have a firmness level of between 6 and 8 on a scale of 1 to 10.

A firm mattress will provide your baby with the kind of support it needs to stay healthy as it grows. A mattress that is too soft can hurt your baby’s developing spine and cause another problem.

What Are the Types of Crib Mattresses?

Innerspring vs. Foam Crib Mattress

If you are an expecting parent, you will probably try to decide which crib mattress type is best for your baby. The two most common types of crib mattresses are the foam crib mattress and the spring crib mattress.

Both of these types of mattresses are excellent choices, and both have their own advantages and disadvantages. The Crib mattress that is best for your baby will depend on several factors, including your budget and whether you plan to use a Crib mattress cover or sheets and blankets.

Innerspring Crib Mattress

Innerspring mattresses are the traditional choice for crib mattress manufacturers. They were the first type of mattresses used in cribs during the 19th century, and they are still the most popular choice to this day. The material for an innerspring crib mattress is either steel, coiled wire, or a combination of both.

The steel is shaped into coils which are then reinforced with mesh wire to hold them in their shape. The coils and wire are then encased in a padding layer used to help spread the baby’s weight over the mattress. There are three basic types of innerspring mattresses, low profile, standard, and high profile.

A spring mattress is a perfect choice for your baby’s crib, and there are a variety of reasons why. First, the spring mattress provides a comfortable and supportive sleeping surface. 

The springs and individually wrapped coils offer just the right amount of support for your baby’s head and spine. It is also an extremely durable choice for your child. You don’t have to worry about your infant outgrowing the crib too quickly or the mattress wearing out quickly. The springs in the mattress allow for extra support, and the coils help ensure that your child maintains the correct body alignment throughout the night.

Foam Crib Mattress

Many parents are now familiar with the importance of having a mattress explicitly made for a crib. A crib mattress, of course, is different from a regular bed mattress. It must meet specific safety requirements to be used in a crib. One type of mattress that can meet all of these safety requirements is a foam mattress for a crib.

A foam mattress for a crib is a great way to keep your baby in a safe and comfortable sleeping environment. Foam mattresses are becoming increasingly popular for use in cribs because of their ability to provide a comfortable sleeping surface without the risk of suffocation caused by materials such as down, cotton, and wool.

Also, foam mattresses help prevent your baby from suffering from allergies and skin rashes as they are made entirely from hypoallergenic materials. For these reasons and many more, foam mattresses for cribs are an excellent choice for any family with a young baby.


What kind of material should I look for when buying a baby crib mattress?

When purchasing a baby crib mattress, you should look for materials that are firm and able to provide ample support for your baby. The ideal materials for this purpose are firm and breathable foam, as well as innerspring mattresses with high-grade steel coils. 

Are baby crib mattresses durable?

Yes, baby crib mattresses are designed to last for several years. Ideally, you should change your baby’s mattress every two to three years to ensure that the mattress remains hygienic and supportive. 

Is there a difference between a crib mattress and a twin mattress?

Yes, there is a significant difference between baby crib mattresses and twin mattresses. Baby crib mattresses are specifically designed to fit a baby’s crib, whereas twin mattresses are larger and may not fit in a baby’s crib. Additionally, baby crib mattresses are typically made from firmer materials for the purpose of providing better support for your baby. 

Are baby crib mattresses waterproof?

Yes, most baby crib mattresses are designed with waterproof coverings in order to protect them from spills and accidents.

What is the best type of baby crib mattress?

This ultimately depends on your individual needs and preferences. However, generally, a firm, foam mattress is the best option for baby crib mattresses, as foam provides excellent support and cushioning for growing bodies.

How do I choose the right firmness for my baby’s crib mattress?

You should choose the firmness of your baby’s crib mattress based on your baby’s size and age. Infants and young children have softer bodies and therefore may require a softer mattress. Older children, on the other hand, require a firmer mattress with more support.

Are baby crib mattresses expensive?

The cost of baby crib mattresses can vary significantly depending on the type and features of the mattress. Generally, baby crib mattresses range from around $50 to $200.

How often should I replace my baby crib mattress?

It is recommended that you replace your baby crib mattress every two to three years in order to ensure that the mattress remains hygienic and supportive.

What type of mattress is best for firmness?

The best type of mattress for firmness is generally innerspring mattresses with high-grade steel coils, as these mattresses provide excellent support and comfort.

What size should a baby crib mattress be?

Baby crib mattresses should always be 27.5 inches wide with a length of 51.5 inches. For a standard baby crib, the mattress should fit snugly and not have more than 1 inch of space between the mattress and the bed frame.

Is it safe to buy a used baby crib mattress?

It is not recommended that you purchase a used baby crib mattress, as it may be unsafe due to hygienic issues. Additionally, used mattresses likely contain less support due to wear and tear.

Nick Favreau

Nick Favreau is an expert mattress writer, whose unbiased reviews and in-depth analyses of mattresses have made him a trusted source of information for those looking for quality sleep.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply
      Enable registration in settings - general